Prospect Profile: Max McCormick

Max McCormick (LW, 5’11, DOB 1992, 6-171/11)
2009-10 USHS Notre Dame 29-38-37-75 (ppg 2.58) 1st pts
2010-11 USHL Sioux City 55-21-21-42 +6 102pim (ppg 0.76) 4th all-star
2011-12 NCAA Ohio 27-10-12-22 -6 31pim (ppg 0.81) t-3rd all-rookie

The former Wisconsin Mr. Hockey winner (ranked #161 by Central Scouting) enjoyed a strong if injury-plagued rookie season with Ohio State (he was named to the CCHA all-rookie team).  McCormick is a well-rounded player with a physical edge.  Playing with fellow Senator draft pick Ryan Dzingel, he’s a long term prospect who will likely finish his NCAA career before turning pro.  Hockey’s Future writes “While no one of area of his game is exceptional, he plays an honest two-way game. Offensively, his shooting ability is his biggest strength, and he is also a play-maker who recognizes open areas and can distribute the puck effectively.”  Describing himself he said “My overall smarts of the game and sense of the game really got a lot better this year [10-11]. It’s a really competitive league [USHL] because everyone is trying to move on. The players are trying to move on, the coaches are trying to move on, even the refs are trying to move on. It’s really competitive and makes it a lot of fun, and it improved my game a lot.”  His Sioux City coach Luke Strand said “He has the attributes of an offensive player with speed, a good stick and the complete level to win battles and be physical“.  Here’s McCormick fighting in the USHL and here’s an interview with him after he was drafted.

Senators News: May 5th

-The Sens have re-signed Peter Regin, who will get a chance to show if he’s truly recovered from his shoulder surgeries.  Ken Warren reports he’ll be paid 800k for the season, which is a 20% drop in salary.  Tim Murray said “We’re very happy to get Peter into the fold. He has had a tough two years with injuries, but when he was not injured, he was certainly a top nine forward (capable of playing on the top three lines), with good offensive skills.”

-Here’s my look at Ottawa’s roster decisions in the off-season.

Don Brennan indulges in all kinds of speculation:
1. The Sens should re-sign Chris Kelly (to serve as an “example” for the other Senators–presumably Brennan thinks the current vets aren’t doing a good enough job in that respect)
2. Ollie Jokinen could help (I’m not sure how–isn’t Turris their second-line center?)
3. P. A. Parenteau or Brad Boyes could provide secondary scoring (the former has stated his intention to stay with the Islanders, while the latter is coming off an atrocious season)
4. Suggests Barret Jackman, Bryan Allen or Kent Huskins to replace Filip Kuba if he walks (for those wondering, they had 13, 14, and 7 points, which combines to just beat Kuba‘s total of 32 for the year)
5. Shane O’Brien to replace Matt Carkner if the latter is let go (the same O’Brien who has played for four different organisations over the last four seasons)
As dismissive as I am of his suggestions, the normally sober Lyle Richardson thinks they are sensible.  Brennan also thinks the team should trade Craig Anderson because his trade value is high–he thinks they could acquire the defensive defenseman the organisation says they need as well as the offensive forward Brennan thinks they need.  The idea is, of course, absurd and Brennan is just trying to be provocative.

Tim Murray made some interesting comments about Binghamton, “I think what we’re trying to do here is sign our own players from within the organization, that have either been drafted or traded here, get them done first of all and see where they fit. I think that in Binghamton, obviously we have to improve our personnel down there, surround our prospects and kids down there with better players and better people, on the veteran side of things. So, at this point, that’s what we’re trying to do. Some of those signings certainly won’t be until after July 1 if they come from other teams.”  What interests me is the comment about “better people” on the veteran side of things, which makes me wonder about which veterans are being referred too (not, presumably, Corey Locke or Francis Lessard who were with the team last year, or Mike McKenna who received a lot of praise, but presumably Mark Parrish or Tim Conboy).

-Here’s my profile of Sens prospect Darren Kramer.

-The Calgary Flames signed KHL free agent Roman Cervenka and Ryan Kennedy throws a hissy-fit about it.  Kennedy, who says nothing specific about Cervenka, compares his signing with other failed European and NCAA experiments without making useful comparisons to those players or looking at the specifics of Cervenka‘s contract (his contract is based on games played, and other bonuses, plus has a European re-assignment clause so he can be sent back to Omsk).  Cervenka is a 26-year old, slightly undersized (5’11) left-handed center who played on the Czech 2005 WJC team, but went undrafted.  He didn’t generate NHL interest until he dominated the Czech league in 2009-10 and played for the 2010 Olympic team.  Last summer he was considered one of the best players in Europe (51-31-30-61 in the KHL playing with Jaromir Jagr), but his production slipped this year (54-23-16-39), although he still lead his team in scoring.  Here’s who Kennedy compared him too (I’m ignoring the NCAA flops since they are completely irrelevant):
1. Jaroslav Hlinka (2007) – the 5’10 30-year old was coming off a career year in the Czech league and was signed by Colorado; he put up decent numbers (63-8-20-28), but not the top-six numbers some were hoping for.  Hlinka never put up the gaudy numbers Cervenka has in Europe and was an older player, so the comparison isn’t apt
2. Fabrian Brunnstrom (2008) – the 6’1 23-year old was a prospect hyped after a strong rookie year with Farejstad in the SEL; he’s never quite progressed as hoped, but he was a prospect not a European pro so there’s no comparison to Cervenka
3. Ville Leino (2008) – the 6’1 24-year old was signed after a monster year in the SM-Liiga; after a year of paying his dues in the AHL for Detroit he didn’t make an impact until his playoff performance with Philadelphia in 2010.  He played reasonably well the following season (81-19-34-53), but because he struggled this year Kennedy thinks he’s finished as a player.  Putting the hyperbole aside, this is a closer comparison, although Leino‘s pre-North American resume isn’t Cervenka‘s either
I think the risk the Flames are taking is a worthwhile one.  Cervenka likely isn’t a top-six talent in the NHL (very few players outside the league are), but given the lack of prospects in the Flames organisation it’s worth giving him a shot and the money it costs the organisation isn’t unreasonable.

Ottawa Senator Roster Decisions for 2012-13

With Ottawa’s 2011-12 season complete the team faces a number of roster decisions.  The organisation is starting year two of the rebuild (or re-tool) and other than wanting to sign a veteran defensive defenseman Bryan Murray has given few indications what changes they will make.  Their UFA’s and RFA’s are listed below (NHL to AHL, from oldest to youngest), with those likely to depart in red and those likely to stay in green (I’ve missed my chance to look smart in predicting Peter Regin would be re-signed as the Sens have done so before I posted this).  I’ll also look at players still under contract who may be moved.

Forward UFA
Zenon Konopka (31) – scratched for more than a quarter of the season, his playoff performance is not enough to save a player who didn’t show up for the regular season
Jesse Winchester (28) – concussion problems and a consistent lack of production means he won’t be back
Rob Klinkhammer (25) – a spare part on the roster, I think the influx of young talent will see him let go
Mark Parrish (35) – the veteran couldn’t stay healthy and his production was subpar, so he’ll be gone
Francis Lessard (32) – the pugilist was scratched for a third of the season and won’t be back
Corey Locke (27) – arguably the best player in the AHL and while I’m sure they’d love to retain him, if he wants NHL games he’ll have to go elsewhere

Defence UFA
Filip Kuba (35) – had a great year and contributed to Karlsson‘s development, but with Melynyk looking to save money he will likely move on
Matt Carkner (31) – has bad knees and was scratched for a quarter of the season; may be kept to fill the heavyweight role, but is otherwise gone
Matt Gilroy (27) – deadline acquisition was invisible and won’t be retained
Tim Conboy (30) – performed up to expectations and could be retained, although the priority for an AHL vet on the blueline is an offensive dynamo which he is not

Forward RFA
Nick Foligno (24) – consistently inconsistent, but will definitely be back
Kaspars Daugavins (23) – not many undersized players earn checking roles, so he’s iffy
Jim O’Brien (23) – was excellent this season and will be retained
Pat Cannone (25) – a solid season for the college grad will see him retained
Stephane Da Costa (22) – despite some struggles I don’t see the Sens giving up on him after one season
Nikita Filatov (21) – he’ll be qualified, but will play in the KHL

Defence RFA
Erik Karlsson (21) – no question he’ll be re-signed
Eric Gryba (24) – the organisation likes him so he’ll be retained
Craig Schira (24) – has never really progressed so he’ll be let go

Goaltender UFA
Alex Auld (31) – was awful and will walk
Mike McKenna (29) – was solid, but I don’t see him being retained as the organisation will want Lehner to be the undisputed starter

Players under contract (discussion below):
Forwards: Daniel Alfredsson (39), Chris Neil (32), Jason Spezza (28), Milan Michalek (27), Colin Greening (26), Peter Regin (26), Erik Condra (25), Bobby Butler (25), Zack Smith (24), Kyle Turris (22), Corey Cowick (23), David Dziurzynski (22), Mike Hoffman (22), Louie Caporusso (22), Derek Grant (22), Cole Schneider (21), Andre Petersson (21), Jakob Silfverberg (21), Wacey Hamilton (21), Mark Stone (19), Mika Zibanejad (19)
Defence: Sergei Gonchar (38), Chris Phillips (34), Jared Cowen (20), Ben Blood (23), Mark Borowiecki (22), Chris Wideman (22), Patrick Wiercioch (21)
Goaltenders: Craig Anderson (30), Ben Bishop (25), Robin Lehner (20)

There aren’t many question marks among the players under contract (I think Alfredsson will return, incidentally), but Bobby Butler is coming off an atrocious season while in the minors Corey Cowick has yet to become an AHL-regular.  I believe Butler will be moved (as early as the draft, as late as training camp) with a chance that Cowick will be sent to another organisation as well.

There are prospects who must be put under contract or the team will lose their rights: Jakub Culek, Marcus Sorensen, and Darren Kramer.  The latter is expected to be signed and help police Binghamton, but the two 2010 draft picks are bigger question marks.  Culek and Sorensen haven’t grown as expected and I suspect in the case of the undersized Swede he will be let go.  Culek‘s potential (and size) might earn him a contract.

A few other prospects are eligible be play in Binghamton due to age (Shane Prince and Jean-Gabriel Pageau) or being drafted from Europe (Fredrik Claesson).  I don’t see room for the former pair, particularly given how small Binghamton’s forward group already is.  Claesson is an interesting case however, given that Djurgarden has been relegated and Binghamton is short on the blueline.  There’s a decent chance he’ll be signed to play in the minors.

Finally, a couple of notes: there’s a possibility the Sens might sign Jack Downing to a contract.  Playing with an AHL-contract this season, he showed a great deal of improvement and Binghamton could use his size in their lineup.  As an older player however, it remains an “if”.  On a different note, former Binghamton blueliner Geoff Kinrade was qualified as an RFA last year, but chose to go to Europe.  He has a contract in the NLA with Bern, but it’s always possible he has an “out” clause and that the organisation could convince him to return.

Overall I believe only four regulars from the Sens lineup will change with the effect greatest on the blueline.  This would be the hypothetical roster based on my assumptions:
NHL forwards (13)
Alfredsson
Neil
Spezza
Michalek
Greening
Regin
Condra
Foligno
Smith
Daugavins
Turris
O’Brien
Silfverberg

NHL defensemen (6)
Gonchar
Phillips
*defensive defenseman*
Karlsson
Cowen
Borowiecki

NHL goaltenders (2)
Anderson
Bishop

AHL forwards (14)
Cannone
Downing
Da Costa
Dziurzynski
Hoffman
Caporusso
Grant
Schneider
Petersson
Hamilton
Kramer
Stone
Culek
Zibanejad

AHL defensemen (7)
Conboy
*offensive defenseman*
Gryba
Blood
Wideman
Wiercioch
Claesson

AHL goaltenders (2)
Lehner
*veteran*

Prospect Profile: Darren Kramer

Darren Kramer (C-L, 6’1, DOB 1991, 6-156/11)
2009-10 AJHL Grande Prairie 58-19-11-30 331pim (ppg 0.51) 7th pts
2010-11 WHL Spokane 68-7-7-14 +10 306pim (ppg 0.20) 18th
2011-12 WHL Spokane 71-21-19-40 +4 200pim (ppg 0.56) 7th

The unranked overage draft pick was considered the best fighter in the draft (47 majors!) and a great team guy.  The Sens sent him to Spokane for his final year of junior with instructions to work on his skills and he responded with a career best in goals and assists (reducing his fisticuffs down to 26).  There’s no doubt he will be signed and join Binghamton in the fall.  Describing himself he said, “People ask me why I do it and I say ‘if I could score 47 goals, I’d do it that way. But after you get to a certain age, you see the guys get better and spots become limited on teams. So I figured out (fighting) was something I enjoyed doing and I wasn’t too bad at it, either. I started fighting and playing an energy role. But I didn’t fight just to fight. I did it for the right reasons and tried to pick my spots properly and try to motivate the team and the crowd at times.”  His coach Don Nachbaur said “He’s been a breath of fresh air. He doesn’t wear a letter but this is a credit to him, I’d name him as one of the leaders on this hockey team and I think every guy in that locker room feels the same. He’s an intelligent player. He knows the situation. He doesn’t fight for himself. He’s the ultimate team guy, he does it for his team. I can’t think of an instance he got into a fight because some guy hit him too hard. It’s always been about the team first.”  Here’s Kramer fighting Dalton Thrower earlier this season.  Finally, I can’t help but reference Kramer’s invention (a new kind of peanut butter jar).

Senators News: May 3rd

Bruce Garrioch lists his top-five priorities for the Sens:
1. Bring back Daniel Alfredsson
Given that this isn’t the club’s decision and there’s nothing more they can do to tell him how much they want him to say, so there’s no effort left to give–he will or he won’t return of his own volition
2. Sign Erik Karlsson
This is the team’s #1 priority and I have no doubt that it will happen
3. Re-sign Chris Kelly
Garrioch believes the Sens haven’t filled the void left when Kelly was dealt and I can’t disagree more–the organisation is full of checkers (Zack Smith, Erik Condra, Jim O’Brien, etc) and has an over abundance of forwards in general (Lyle Richardson aslo points out that Kelly wants to stay a Bruin and that his salary demands are unlikely to fit into the Sens salary structure)
4. Trade Sergei Gonchar
Garrioch thinks he should have produced more points (he was the 23rd highest scorer among blueliners) for the money he makes; given the lack of depth on the blueline this makes less sense than Garrioch’s desire to trade Filip Kuba last year
5. Buy out Bobby Butler
With Eugene Melnyk counting his pennies a trade would be more likely; I can see Butler being moved, although it may be a training camp decision rather than something this summer

-Bryan Murray talked about Jakob Silfverberg saying, “He’s a very good player. I think he’s a very talented player. There were several shifts in a tight series (against the Rangers) wher he showed that he’s going to be a good hockey player in this league. He’s going to be a point getter. My expectation is that he’ll be exactly that. He’ll probably come to camp and force me to talk to Paul once in awhile and suggest that maybe he play in a top-six position at times. He’s that kind of player.”  There’s no reason to doubt that Silfverberg will be on the NHL roster next season.

-Here’s my profile of Jean-Gabriel Pageau.

-Sens prospect Marcus Sorensen signed a one-year contract with Djurgarden.

Prospect Profile: Jean-Gabriel Pageau

Jean-Gabriel Pageau (C/RW, 5’9, DOB 1992, 4-96/11)
2009-2010 QMJHL Gatineau 62-16-15-31 +4 20pim (ppg 0.50) 7th pts
2010-11 QMHL Gatineau 67-32-47-79 +23 22pim (ppg 1.17) 1st
2011-12 QMJHL Gat/Chicoutimi 46-32-33-65 Even 25pim (ppg 1.41) 3rd

Ottawa’s second undersized forward of the draft (after Shane Prince), Pageau was not ranked by Central Scouting, although every other scouting agency had him listed (#102 by ISS for example).  Pierre Dorion is a huge fan of Pageau‘s, who was the dominating leader for Gatineau before a trade to Chicoutimi saw a drop in his production.  Because he’s very responsible defensively, it may seem less incumbent on Pageau to score at the next level, but there aren’t many undersized checking centers.  Pageau talked about his motivation after being drafted, “You saw a lot of players (drafted) before me, good players, too, but I know I can play with them. I know there’s a lot of good players in the first round, second round, third round, but I know I can play with them. So I’m not stressed about it.” AndI think there’s good examples in the NHL [of smaller guys]. There’s small players with every team, and I believe and I hope that I’m going to be the next one. I don’t get affected [by] people always saying you’re too small [and] not strong enough – I work hard to get stronger so I’m not afraid of that“.  There’s little reason to doubt that he will be signed, although another year of junior hockey is a possibility.  The Hockey News said, “Hardworking and very talented, size is an obvious handicap”, while Red Line Report saidAnother midget with 2nd round skills, but no size.”  Here’s Pageau in a rare fight and here he is scoring a goal.

Senators News: May 1st

-With the season over and weeks before the draft and free agency, the news digest will not remain consistently daily.  I still have several prospect profiles to post (Jean-Gabriel Pageau is next), but in general posts will be a little more haphazard until the draft.  You can check my Twitter feed for posting news.

Eugene Melnyk is dreaming in technicolor if he truly believes his public statements about Erik Karlsson being “reasonable” will have any effect on contract negotiations.  Karlsson deserves and will get a big contract from the Senators.  Melnyk’s comment that the team can’t be among the cap limit teams is an interesting change of philosophy for the organisation, but one I think fans will reject if they start seeing top players depart because the team can’t afford them.  Fortunately for ownership, Bryan Murray has done such a good job bringing in prospects there’s little need for the team to be among the big spenders in the near future.

-As has been reported everywhere, Paul MacLean was been nominated (as expected) for the Jack Adams trophy.  As I’ve said before, I’m indifferent to awards in the NHL–virtually every decision is debatable, including who does or doesn’t get nominated.  It’s a nice gesture for MacLean who did a fantastic job this year, but whether he wins it or not has no impact on his performance next season.

Hockey’s Future has listed their top-50 prospects (along with those who just_missed_the_cut).  You should take the website with a grain of salt, but here’s how Sens prospects were positioned in their list:
5. Mika Zibanejad
35. Jakob Silfverberg
44. Robin Lehner
Mark Stone
received consideration but didn’t make the list

Senators News: April 30th

Ken Warren channels his inner Popeye and declares that Jason Spezza is what he is.  There’s not much new here, but Warren does share an interesting anecdote, “After a preseason game last September, I had a drink with a long-time NHL executive as we talked about what we both thought would be a long, difficult season ahead for the Senators. When he asked if I thought there was any chance the Senators could be competitive and challenge for a playoff spot, I suggested only if goaltender Craig Anderson could steal them at least half a dozen games. He said the Senators wouldn’t get there because Spezza couldn’t get them there. I’m guessing he wasn’t alone in his opinion at that time.”  There’s no #1 center waiting in the wings for the Senators so they are hitched to the Spezza wagon; what the team needs (and is developing) is secondary scoring so there’s less pressure on him (which they did very well throughout the regular season).

Andrew Duffy has a long piece about Erik Karlsson that delves into his background and his play with Ottawa up to this point.  For those who want insight into his personal journey it’s worth a read.  The part that stuck out to me was, “In his first NHL season, 2008-09, the 19-year-old was sent to the minors nine games into the year without a goal to his name. Karlsson was upset, breaking down with emotion when Murray delivered the bad news.”  I don’t recall hearing that reported at the time.

Nichols wonders if it’s time to trade Milan Michalek.  He offers six points: 1. Selling high, 2. His numbers are inflated (versus career averages), 3. Contract situation (his actual salary his higher than his cap hit), 4. Age (he turns 28 in December), 5. Replacements in the offing (Jakob Silfverberg, Mika Zibanejad, Mark Stone), and 6. Trade to help an aging blueline.  It’s an interesting argument and one I find persuasive (the odds of Michalek having back-to-back healthy seasons are virtually nil), but I doubt management see’s it that way.

Jeremy Milks takes a look at potential roster changes for the Sens, but writes Garrioch-styled opinion without analysis.  He suggests Butler, Kuba, Gilroy, and Auld could go while guessing ReginKonopka, Daugavins, and Carkner will be retained.  It’s going to be a crowded lineup with Milks as GM, since presumably Konopka and Carkner would reside in the pressbox until the playoffs arrived.  Incidentally, I apparently don’t have a heart and I hate Christmas, because those are the only people not fond of Chris Phillips as a player.

Senators News: April 29th

-Here’s my review of the Sens in the playoffs.

Paul MacLean talked about his first season coaching in the NHL, “I feel good about the fact I can coach in the league and we’ve had satisfaction, so I guess I give myself credibility that I can do this. But now the hard part is to do it again. I remember when I scored 30 goals for the first time, and I was all pumped up about it and an old guy, Floyd Thomson, said ‘Oh yeah? well now you’ve got to do it again.’ I feel the same way today. That’s a motivator for me, and it also scares me to death. Because I know how hard it is, and it’s hard to do. But I’m looking forward to it, and I’m excited about September, of getting back for training camp and getting started again. But I’m also scared to death.”

Bryan Murray made an interesting comment regarding his second line, “Up front, we’re always looking for somebody to step in and score goals. That line with (captain Daniel Alfredsson) played with Turris, if we had one more guy that could score consistently or be a 20-to-25 goal scorer would make our team different.”  That’s a shot across the bow at Nick Foligno.  Murray also said the team needs another defensive defencemen which might come internally or externally.

Joy Lindsay Tweets that “[Bryan] Murray said he told Lehner that Bishop‘s one-way can be managed, but that org likes goalies to play in minors — and win“, apparently without a sense of irony since Lehner has already won the Calder Cup.

Ian Mendes Tweets that “[Bryan] Murray says he will not automatically qualify all of his RFAs“, but implies Nick Foligno will be back by saying “he challenged Nick Foligno in their exit meeting. Wants him to prove he’s a 2nd liner.”

Peter Regin talked about his status going forward, “It was a different injury this time. It wasn’t the same. I guess I was just unlucky that it was the same body part on the same side, so it looked bad that way. I’m confident, the doctors are confident, so it shouldn’t be a problem.”

Bruce Garrioch grades the Sens and I’ll delve into his comments after listing the grades (Regin and Gilroy were not assessed):
A+ Karlsson, Alfredsson
A Anderson, Spezza, Paul MacLean, Bryan Murray
B+ Cowen, Phillips, Neil, Michalek
B Kuba, Gonchar, Turris, Greening, Bishop
B- Foligno
C+ Carkner, Smith, Condra, Konopka, O’Brien, Winchester
C- Daugavins
D Auld
F Butler

As you’d expect there are oddities in Garrioch’s assessment.  You’d think MacLean and Murray would warrant an A+; Phillips (as always with Ottawa’s media) is given the grade of a teacher’s pet; how Kuba is only a B is difficult to understand, but Garrioch doesn’t provide a rationale for how he grades players, so there’s nothing to evaluate how grades are assigned.  Winchester does not deserve a C+, while Smith, Condra and Daugavins deserve better grades; I’m not sure why Auld doesn’t get the same failing grade Butler earns.

Now for the odder statements from Garrioch: he wants Carkner to be retained–the same player who has a bad knee and can’t play during the regular season; he says Gonchar showed veteran leadership in the playoffs, but will likely be dealt in the off-season (no reason is provided for why); he speculates Chris Kelly might be brought back because…well, no reason is provided; he says Winchester has a role when healthy–what role?  There’s nothing he offers that other players don’t do as well (or better).

Jean-Gabriel Pageau‘s season is over as Chicoutimi was knocked out of the QMJHL playoffs.

Ottawa Senators: Playoff Review

The Ottawa Senators lost in seven games to the President’s Trophy winning New York Rangers.  Six of the seven games were decided by one goal, with the other game having a two-goal margin.  While this is a fantastic accomplishment for a team thought to be among the worst in the NHL coming into the season, the loss stings as Ottawa had two chances to close out the Rangers, but couldn’t get the deal done.

Here’s a look at how player performed throughout the series with my analysis and a grade for each player (A=outstanding season, B=above expectations, C=expectations met, D=below expectations, F=well below expectations; TOI=time on ice, FO%=faceoff percentage, INJ=games missed due to injury, SCR=scratched):
Jason Spezza 7-3-2-5 +2 20:58 FO% 54.3 Grade D
Was unable to bring up the level of his game to help a team starved for offence
Sergei Gonchar 7-1-3-4 +1 TOI 24:35 Grade B
Solid in all zones and his TOI was higher than in the regular season to reflect that
Nick Foligno 7-1-3-4 TOI 15:10 -1 Grade C
Played like he has his whole career–great one minute, invisible the next, then takes a bad penalty
Chris Neil 7-2-1-3 +2 TOI 13:35 Grade B
At his best in the most physical games
Kyle Turris
7-1-2-3 -1 TOI 16:37 FO% 39.7 Grade C
Couldn’t carry the offensive load when Spezza disappeared, but play well throughout
Daniel Alfredsson 4-2-0-2 -3 TOI 17:57 INJ 3 Grade C
The only elite forward to really show up in every game, but that’s what you expect from Alfie
Milan Michalek 7-1-1-2 +3 TOI 21:53 Grade D
He was excellent defensively, but the team needed him to produce and he couldn’t bury his chances
Filip Kuba 7-0-2-2 +1 TOI 23:25 Grade C
He continued his solid play from the regular season
Zenon Konopka 6-0-2-2 +2 TOI 11:17 FO% 70.7 SCR 1 Grade B
It’s amazing that a guy who was completely useless during the regular season could turn in a solid performance at playoff time, but his effectiveness dropped considerably as the series moved away from its early, chaotic start
Erik Karlsson 7-1-0-1 Even TOI 25:21 Grade D
He was one of Ottawa’s better players in the series, but he couldn’t provide the expected offensive contribution
Erik Condra
7-1-0-1 Even TOI 11:40 Grade C
Solid throughout; he played on every line during the series
Colin Greening
7-0-1-1 +1  TOI 13:59 Grade C
His offensive production could have been a little higher, but he provided much needed jam
Zack Smith 7-0-1-1 -2 TOI 13:21 FO% 53.7 Grade C
Showed a number of offensive flashes and was solid in his grinding role
Chris Phillips 7-0-1-1 Even TOI 21:33 Grade C
Just like the regular season, sometimes he helped his own team, sometimes he helped the Rangers
Jared Cowen 7-0-1-1 -3 TOI 17:01 Grade D
Much like the second half of the season, Cowen struggled with decision making
Jim O’Brien 7-0-1-1 Even  TOI 8:37 FO% 48.4 Grade B
A great series for O’Brien who gave the team all he had in limited ice time
Matt Carkner 4-0-1-1 +1 TOI 7:02 SCR 1 INJ 2 Grade B
Provided toughness when it was needed, but his wonky knee knocked him out of the series
Mark Stone 1-0-1-1 +1 TOI 8:43 SCR 6 Grade incomplete
Added to the lineup when it became apparent Butler had nothing to give; played well with limited minutes
Jesse Winchester 4-0-0-0 -2 TOI 10:52 FO% 52.0 INJ 3 Grade D
In the lineup largely for faceoffs and to grind, he wasn’t very effective and then was concussed
Bobby Butler 3-0-0-0 Even TOI 12:44 SCR 4 Grade F
Had yet more chances to show something, but remained invisible and was scratched in favour of prospects
Matt Gilroy 3-0-0-0 Even TOI 12:55 SCR 4 Grade F
Added nothing to the lineup in limited, laconic play
Jakob Silfverberg 2-0-0-0 Even TOI 9:10 Grade incomplete
While occasionally confused in coverages, he showed glimpses of the talent to come
Kaspars Daugavins 1-0-0-0 -1 TOI 10:30 SCR 6 Grade incomplete
Only appeared in game one
Craig Anderson 7-3-4 2.00 GAA .933 SV% Grade C
He had to at least equal Lundqvist in his play and he simply couldn’t

Players who were available but did not play: Mike Hoffman, Andre Petersson, Stephane Da Costa, David Dziurzynski, Mark Borowiecki, Eric Gryba, Patrick Wiercioch, Ben Bishop, and Robin Lehner.

Looking at performances as a whole the Sens remained just shy of what they needed.  Top offensive players couldn’t produce enough and Anderson couldn’t rescue the team often enough.  The players who went beyond expectations were mostly veterans with low expectations (Konopka, Carkner, Neil) or rookies (O’Brien), with only Gonchar among the better players lifting his level of play.  The playoffs didn’t particularly hurt the futures of any player, as marginal guys like Gilroy and Butler are already on their way out.  As a team I think the primary reason the Sens lost was the top-six forward group, specifically Spezza and Michalek failing to produce.

Throughout the series I named players as top-performers or as players who struggled (Karlsson and Anderson were tied for the most top-performer nods, while Spezza lead the way for players who struggled):
Erik Karlsson 3/0
Daniel Alfredsson 2/0
Jim O’Brien 2/0
Craig Anderson 3/2
Nick Foligno 1/0
Kyle Turris 1/0
Chris Neil 1/0
Filip Kuba 1/0
Bobby Butler 0/1
Chris Phillips 1/2
Milan Michalek 0/2
Jason Spezza 1/4