Senators News: June 15th

Bryan Murray is putting the Sens first round pick (#15) up for grabs.  “There are people on this team who we are not really interested in trading. But it may well happen that we would try to do something to either add a player or a higher pick. We’re very open minded. So if it gets out there that other managers would like to call, I’d be very open with that. There aren’t a lot of contracts I’m trying to dump. I think the people that have them, have a chance to play on our hockey team. During the training camp process, or after that, if some young player steps up and is really showing that he is ready to play now, I have to try to look after that at the time.  It’s always been my theory that you pick the best player … at that time. And if you have to move him to get what you need later on, you probably can do that.”  This isn’t an unusual or unexpected sentiment for Murray, who has made trades every single draft as Ottawa’s GM.  Mind you, it’s one thing to be ready to deal and it’s another to find a dance partner.

Pierre Dorion is also talking about the draft, “With the way the 2010-11 season ended, with us trading away a lot of assets, we approached last year as a very big draft. I think we go into this draft with a different mindset in that we know we’re not going to pick as often as we did last year. But we still go into it with the mindset that you never know what’s going to happen. We’re dealing from a position of power now when it comes to the quality prospects we have. A number of these players won the Calder Cup (in 2011), and a number of them played and contributed on our team this year. I think at every position we have what I would call blue-chip prospects. Some are playing right now, some will be playing down the road. There are some bigger names at the top [of the draft], but I see quite a few good players. Whether they make it next year, or whether it will take them one year or three years to make it will depend on their learning curves, physically and mentally. If you get caught up in drafting by position, you’re not drafting the best asset.”  To me these comments compliment Murray’s desire for wheeling and dealing quite well.

-Not surprisingly Murray doesn’t expect to be very busy when it comes to free agency.  There’s a need to fill a hole on the blueline, but otherwise nothing is certain.

Alan Panzeri offers the names of six players the Sens might be eyeing for the draft: Sebastien Collberg, Hampus Lindholm, Pontus Aberg, Ollie Maata, Cody Ceci, and Radek Faksa.  It’s an interesting list, but Panzeri doesn’t indicate whether it comes from his best guess or from talking to the organisation, so take it with a grain of salt.

Sportsnet provides their list of top-five players rising in the draft: Tom Wilson, Derrick Pouliot, Teuvo Teravainen, Cody Ceci, and Lukas Sutter.  The only nonsensical member of this list is Ceci, who was highly regarded at the beginning of the season.

-Mock drafts abound and THN see’s Ottawa selecting Hampus Lindholm.  The NHL website has three mock drafts posted.  Mike G. Morreale has Ottawa picking Matt Finn, Adam Kimelman see’s Ottawa picking Cody Ceci, and Steven Hoffner follows the trend of Ottawa picking Hampus Lindholm.

-The Sens have posted video of their amateur scouting meeting.  The best part of this to me is watching Vaclav Burda’s expressions.

-For those of you who want a refresher on the various draft resources that I’ve looked at, here are the links:
International Scouting Service (ISS)
Red Line Report
Future Considerations
Hockey Prospects
Mckeen’s
The Hockey News
Hockey Prospectus

Hockey Prospectus’ 2012 NHL Draft Rankings

Hockey Prospectus’ Corey Pronman has a list of his top-125 2012 NHL draft rankings, so here’s a look at his top-30 rankings along with my thoughts about his reasoning.

1.  Nail Yakupov, Left Wing, Sarnia-OHL
2.  Mikhail Grigorenko, Center, Quebec-QMJHL
3.  Alexander Galchenyuk, Center, Sarnia-OHL
4.  Filip Forsberg, Right Wing, Leksands-Allsvenskan
5. Teuvo Teravainen, Left Wing, Jokerit-SM-Liiga
6.  Matt Dumba, Defense, Red Deer-WHL
7. Morgan Rielly, Defense, Moose Jaw-WHL
8. Ryan Murray, Defense, Everett-WHL
9. Pontus Aberg, Left Wing, Djurgarden-SEL
10. Radek Faksa, Center, Kitchener-OHL
11. Sebastian Collberg, Right Wing, Frolunda-SEL
12. Jacob Trouba, Defense, USA Under-18 National Team-USHL
13. Cody Ceci, Defense, Ottawa-OHL
14. Zemgus Girgensons, Center, Dubuque-USHL
15. Griffin Reinhart, Defense, Edmonton-WHL
16. Hampus Lindholm, Defense, Rogle-Allsvenskan
17. Anton Slepyshev, Left Wing, Novokuznetsk-KHL
18. Tomas Hertl, Center, HC Slavia Praha-Czech Extraliga
19. Matt Finn, Defense, Guelph-OHL
20. Ludvig Bystrom, Defense, MODO-SEL
21. Olli Maatta, Defense, London-OHL
22. Nikolai Prokhorkin, Center, CSKA-MHL
23. Slater Koekkoek, Defense, Peterborough-OHL
24. Derrick Pouliot, Defense, Portland-WHL
25. Brendan Gaunce, Center, Belleville-OHL
26. Tim Bozon, Left Wing, Kamloops-WHL
27. Nicolas Kerdiles, Left Wing, USA Under-18 National Team-USHL
28. Daniil Zharkov, Right Wing, Belleville-OHL
29. Ville Pokka, Defense, Karpat-SM-Liiga
30. Scott Laughton, Center, Oshawa-OHL

Pronman talks about his process of ranking the players, “these reports are not based on the work of an independent scouting service. While the reports are based somewhat on my personal viewings of most of the prospects profiled of whom I have seen most play at least once, predominantly though video scouting, a significant portion of my notes come from talking to scouts and NHL execs and accumulating a lot of information from different sources throughout the year. The way I feel I can do my job at its peak is to accumulate as much information as I can, and then use that information to independently assess the value of players. The information I use to assess players does come from sources aside from my own eyes, but the ranking process has zero influence from others. I am a fan of something I’ve borrowed from the baseball scouting world and have adapted to hockey scouting called the 20-80 scale. In short, it is a distinct scouting language, derived originally from using standard deviations to assess talent distributions. To avoid confusing readers, I do not use number grades at all due to the lack of popularity of the scale in hockey circles, however the language I use throughout my reports have a rhyme and reason to which you should be informed about. Here is how I use the 20-80 scale with certain words that you will see in all of my reports: 40 is fringe/replacement level 45 is below average 50 grade is NHL average/average/pro-level/decent 55 is above average 60 is plus/top tier 70 is amongst the NHL’s elite/plus-plus 80 is a generational talent but it is never used in this draft preview.”

I don’t think the 20-80 scale is any clearer than any other numerical or alphabetical system.  Pronman “Together, Fenwick/Corsi and Luck account for around 3/4 of team winning percentage.  What’s the remainder?  Goaltending talent – which Tom Awad estimates at about 5% – and special teams, along with a very small sliver that’s due to shooting talent and the oft-mentioned “shot quality.”  So I don’t think there’s a false dichotomy here – there are five factors in this model, all of which are given credence in proportion to their predictive power.”  He also puts a large emphasis on possession (puck-control).

Because (or despite) Pronman’s approach his rankings are largely in line with other publications except for his shuffling of goaltenders down the rankings.  His first-round selections all match at least one other draft source except for Slepyshev, Prokhorkin and Zharkov.  It’s worthwhile checking Pronman out–there’s no cost and it’s yet another resource for draft fans.

Senators News: June 13th

-The Los Angeles Kings put NHL fans out of their misery by winning the Stanley Cup.  The Kings hammered home the point that the regular season means nothing with the victory.  The unwatchable final produced the third lowest ratings since 1995 (dropping 29% from last year) and NHL purists can pat themselves on the back for sucking excitement from the game.  I’m not sure a team has ever won the Cup with less adversity paired with a complete lack of excitement.  Even the 1995 New Jersey Devils, the poster childs for tedium, struggled to win the Cup.  Call me a pessimist, I predict the NHL will make no meaningful changes for fear of “hurting the game” or some similar nonsense.

Nichols reports that Shane Prince has been signed, although official word has yet to confirm it.

Scott reminds us that Filip Kuba could be retained, although he points to Corsi numbers to show that Erik Karlsson was more important for Kuba‘s performance than the other way around.

Bruce Garrioch speculates that the Sens are interested in retaining Matt Carkner and Jesse Winchester.  I can imagine how difficult it would be to find replacements for a fourth-line center with concussion problems who can’t score and a seventh defenseman with two bad knees who couldn’t keep up with the pace before his injury problems.  Garrioch can’t offer the same assurance for Zenon Konopka, which is about as clear a sign as you could ask for that he won’t be retained.

Wayne Scanlan wonders how close the Sens are to the Kings (assuming that’s the pattern to follow), but doesn’t really spend much time breaking down the comparison other than to say the Sens need internal growth to match them.

Rob Brodie runs down Ottawa’s first round picks throughout the organisations history (including Kyle Turris for no particular reason), which is fun only in that you can remember that Pierre Gauthier and Marshall Johnston thought Mathieu Chouinard was worth selecting twice.

Bob McKenzie confirms that Chris Kelly has re-signed with Boston which mercifully ends the pointless speculation about a return to Ottawa.

Senators News: June 11th

-Things are very quiet on the Sens front.  I expect the signing of Shane Prince this week or next, but otherwise things will likely remain quiet until the draft.

-Not surprisingly, Don Brennan wants Zenon Konopka and Matt Carkner resigned.  Scott has fun deconstructing Brennan’s argument for bringing them back and the smart money won’t see either retained.

-As a sign of how slow things are right now, Jared Crozier jumps into Chris Kelly rumour mode just as Bob McKenzie is closing that door with word he’s about to be re-signed by the Bruins.

John Henkelman looks at the playoff performances by Senator prospects and recent graduates, largely regurgitating stats and inexplicably calling Darren Kramer a defensive prospect.

-Capgeek has their provisional salary up for Jean-Gabriel Pageau (613k).

-Here’s my look at Red Line Report’s 2012 NHL Draft Guide.

Senators News: June 7th

-The Sens signed Jean-Gabriel Pageau to his ELC yesterday.  Tim Murray said “If he has a big summer this summer and comes to training camp in good shape and looks like he can play in the American league, we’ll give him every opportunity to do that. If it doesn’t look like he’s ready for that level yet, we’ll have to talk to him and go through our options. He’d be a star in (the Quebec Major Junior Hockey League), in my opinion, as an overager (next year). But hopefully, he’s strong enough and good enough to play in the American league for us next year.”  Pageau himself talked about his opportunity, “That’s a great offer they gave me and I very much appreciate it. I think that’s a good motivation for the future and for my summer. I think I have a big training season (ahead) and I’m ready to make the sacrifice to be in the organization earlier.”

-Bryan Murray (in the above link) indicated that Shane Prince would be the last prospect signed.

Tim Murray was on The Team 1200 yesterday and commented on free agency and Ottawa’s RFA’s.  In respect to the latter he said, “The RFA guys will be after July 1st but certainly we’ve got a strategy with all of them and we’ve got our comparables, as do the agents have their comparables. So they’ll all get done in due course but there’s no cut-off date and they’ll all get done after July 1st.”  Murray talked about their process with UFA’s where they use a 7-point system to assess players.  More interesting to me was his comment about the glut of forwards in the organisation, “it certainly puts us in a great position to trade quantity for quality and you’re not often in that position but as you said, the drafting has gone very well over the past few years. So we’ve had a lot of signings in the last two years that gets a little worrisome with the 50-man roster, reserve list and all that but we’re in a position where if we can plug a hole or trade quantity for quality, we’re quite willing to do it but again, we need a dance partner.”  To me quantity over quality screams Bobby Butler and more for a defenseman.

Don Brennan keeps his streak of dumb ideas alive with “Chris Phillips could replace Kuba on the number one pairing, alongside Karlsson, and the Senators wouldn’t miss a beat.”  That makes no sense on any level, as Kuba is a better player than Phillips (for the simplest of statistical comparisons, Kuba‘s 32 points this year is 6 more than Phillips‘ career-best in 06-07, while Kuba‘s -1 rating in four years with the Senators is much better than Phillips‘ -29 rating over the same period).

Senators News: June 5th

Bryan Murray implied that Filip Kuba won’t be back with the Senators, “I think we’re moving on. I haven’t heard from him. I talked to his agent before the year ended and told him sort of the thoughts I had, about what we might consider and I haven’t heard back. He’s going to get his money. I think he’s going to get similar money to what he was earning with us. And I’m not going to go there I don’t think.”  This could just be posturing on his part, but I can imagine Kuba wanting to move on.  Murray suggests that one of Mark Borowiecki or Patrick Wiercioch could step in to help replace the departing veteran, but I agree with Nichols that the latter case is largely wishful thinking.

Ken Warren echoes Sun reporters in suggesting Sergei Gonchar is being shopped, which seems pretty pointless given that he has a full no-movement clause until January 1st, 2013.  Until then, moving is Gonchar‘s decision.

-Everyone is wondering why TV ratings are so poor for the Cup final.  Grey Wyshynski thinks it’s a lack of a compelling narrative, while Steve Lepore thinks it’s a lack of star power to create that narrative.  Lyle Richardson makes the more obvious point that it’s due to the style of play, which is the one thing the NHL is unlikely to do anything about.

-Here’s my look at McKeen’s 2012 NHL Draft Guide.  Only one guide remains (Red Line Report) to be reviewed, but it has not yet been released.

McKeen’s 2012 NHL Draft Guide

McKeen’s 2012 NHL draft guide is out and here’s a look at their top-30 rankings along with my thoughts about the publication:

1 Nail Yakupov RW 5-10/190 Sarnia (OHL)
2 Alex Galchenyuk C 6-0/200 Sarnia (OHL)
3 Filip Forsberg C 6-2/180 Leksands (Swe)
4 Ryan Murray D 6-0/195 Everett (WHL)
5 Teuvo Teravainen LW 5-11/165 Jokerit (Fin)
6 Mathew Dumba D 6-0/180 Red Deer (WHL)
7 Griffin Reinhart D 6-4/200 Edmonton (WHL)
8 Morgan Rielly D 5-11/190 Moose Jaw (WHL)
9 Mikhail Grigorenko C 6-3/200 Quebec (QMJHL)
10 Jacob Trouba D 6-2/195 NTDP (USA)
11 Hampus Lindholm D 6-2/195 Rogle (Swe)
12 Cody Ceci D 6-2/205 Ottawa (OHL)
13 Olli Maatta D 6-1/200 London (OHL)
14 Sebastian Collberg RW 5-11/175 Frolunda (Swe)
15 Zemgus Girgensons C 6-1/200 Dubuque (USHL)
16 Radek Faksa C 6-2/200 Kitchener (OHL)
17 Derrick Pouliot D 5-11/190 Portland (WHL)
18 Brendan Gaunce C 6-2/215 Belleville (OHL)
19 Tom Wilson RW 6-3/205 Plymouth (OHL)
20 Matt Finn D 6-0/195 Guelph (OHL)
21 Brady Skjei D 6-3/200 NTDP (USA)
22 Slater Koekkoek D 6-2/185 Peterborough (OHL)
23 Andrei Vasilevski G 6-3/205 Salavat Ufa (Rus)
24 Malcolm Subban G 6-1/190 Belleville (OHL)
25 Scott Laughton C 6-0/180 Oshawa (OHL)
26 Stefan Matteau C 6-1/210 NTDP (USA)
27 Tomas Hertl C 6-2/195 Slavia Praha (Cze)
28 Pontus Aberg LW 5-11/195 Djurgardens (Swe)
29 Colton Sissons C 6-0/190 Kelowna (WHL)
30 Michael Matheson D 6-1/180 Dubuque (USHL)

McKeen’s is less comprehensive than most guides, listing only the top 120-players (ala The Hockey News‘ top-100) with a group of players who get “honourable mentions” (20) and “sleepers” (16), although these are not included in a convenient chart or list.  There’s no discussion of specific NHL teams nor a mock draft.  In terms of their prognostication, I didn’t use McKeen’s in my draft assessments last year so I can’t comment.

There’s no reason to buy the digital copy of this issue, as you are forced to accept redundant material from two newsletters (one from January and the other from March), which inflates the price.  McKeen’s offers less material than all the other guides save THN, but is more expensive than Future Considerations and Hockey Prospect‘s regular draft issue, so it’s not something a draft junkie needs to get hold of.

Senators News: June 2nd

Pierre Dorion talked about the draft, “Our mindset is totally different. With the way the 2010-11 season ended, with us trading away a lot of assets, we approached last year as a very big draft. The biggest thing is last year we were picking sixth and this year we’re picking 15th. So you understand the quality of the prospect will not be of the same value. We drafted a lot of skill last year. What we’ve done in last year’s draft and the three previous drafts is we really improved the depth of our prospects. When Bryan and Tim (Murray, assistant GM) took over, we had three players returning in Binghamton (AHL) and a few players in junior we were going to sign, so the cupboard was really bare. We’re dealing from a position of power now when it comes to the quality prospects we have. A number of these players won the Calder Cup last year (in the AHL), a number of them played and contributed on our team this year. For instance, you look at Jared Cowen coming in from Spokane, and we don’t win the Calder Cup without him. So that experience of winning the Calder Cup was a huge factor in him being able to step into the league this year. I think at every position we have what I would call blue-chip prospects. Some are playing right now, some will be playing down the road.”  He added a thought about the NHL combine, “As far as making a big change, no team that I’ve ever worked with has ever done that based on the combine.”

Ian Altenbaugh ranks Ottawa’s prospects as third best in the NHL.  “Strengths: The Senators have top-end skill at all forward positions led by Mika Zibanejad, Jakob Silfverberg, Stefan Noesen, and Shane Prince. Despite graduating five prospects and trading another key one this season, the team still has a group of players who can provide depth at the NHL level including Stephane Da Costa, Jim O’Brien, Andre Petersson, and Robin Lehner. Ottawa has a very young NHL team so the organization has the luxury of giving their future prospects more time to fully develop properly for the NHL.  Weaknesses: The organization has no goaltending prospects behind Robin Lehner at any level of hockey and needs to address this hole. The Senators have a lack of high-end talent on defense with the graduation of Jared Cowen and the trade of David Rundblad, but do have a good quantity with lower potential.  Top 5 Prospects: 1. Mika Zibanejad, C, 2. Robin Lehner, G, 3. Jakob Silfverberg, LW/RW, 4. Stefan Noesen, RW, 5. Mark Stone, RW. Lost to Graduation: Bobby Butler, Erik Condra, Jared Cowen, Kasper Daugavins, Colin Greening. Lost to Trade: David Rundblad. Added: Cole Schneider.

Wayne Scanlan writes about the style of hockey which has dominated the playoffs, “clogged shooting lanes, skaters restricted from skating freely, with or without the puck, defencemen latching onto forecheckers like airport security personnel doing a full body search.”  Scanlan hopes that the NHL’s “posse of general managers, coaches, players and officials to discuss the state of the game and how rules are enforced,” which will help change the game.  I have my doubts.  Players are conservative, GM’s are conservative, and coaches are incredibly conservative when it comes to change.  What’s more likely to happen is that the defensive trend will continue for another season or two until ratings and attendance begins to tank, then action will be taken.

-Speaking of bad ratings, the Cup final has dropped 25% from last year and I expect that decline to continue.

-Here’s my look at The Hockey News and Hockey Prospect‘s 2012 NHL Draft Guide.

Hockey Prospect’s 2012 NHL Draft Guide

The Hockey Prospect’s 2012 NHL draft guide is out and here’s a look at their top-30 rankings along with my thoughts about the publication:

1. Alex Galchenyuk
2. Nail Yakubov
3. Ryan Murray
4. Griffin Reinhart
5. Zemgus Girgensons
6. Filip Forsberg
7. Jacob Trouba
8. Teuvo Teravainen
9. Morgan Rielly
10. Derrick Pouliot
11. Slater Koekkoek
12. Mikhail Grigorenko
13. Cody Ceci
14. Matt Dumba
15. Radek Faksa
16. Brandan Gaunce
17. Phillip Di Giuseppe
18. Pontus Aberg
19. Thomas Wilson
20. Tomas Hertl
21. Tim Bozon
22. Brady Skjei
23. Dalton Thrower
24. Patrick Sieloff
25. Matthew Finn
26. Olli Maata
27. Andrei Vasilevski
28. Malcolm Subban
29. Colton Sissons
30. Jake Dotchin

This is the so-called “Black Book” edition from Hockey Prospect‘s and despite its girth (over 300 pages) it does not include any specific organisational material nor a mock draft.  HP’s rankings differ radically from the other major publications, with a devaluation of European talent to the benefit of North Americans (particularly US players).  In terms of their prognostication, last year they were the second most accurate among total players drafted (47%), but dead last among player X selected in round X.

There’s no good reason for draft fans to buy this pricey product.  The less expensive version is sold out, but might have been worth it just for HP’s perspective.  The Black Book includes very detailed profiles, but these are no different than those found elsewhere.  The one element that makes the book unique are their game-by-game scouting reports, but it’s hard to imagine many readers need this kind of detail.

The Hockey News 2012 NHL Draft Guide

The Hockey News 2012 NHL draft guide is out and here’s a look at their top-30 rankings along with my thoughts about the publication:

1. Nail Yakubov
2. Filip Forsberg
3. Mikhail Grigorenko
4. Ryan Murray
5. Matt Dumba
6. Morgan Rielly
7. Alex Galchenyuk
8. Griffin Reinhart
9. Jacob Trouba
10. Cody Ceci
11. Radek Faksa
12. Teuvo Teravainen
13. Derrick Pouliot
14. Sebastian Collberg
15. Hampus Lindholm
16. Zemgus Girgensons
17. Brandan Gaunce
18. Matthew Finn
19. Ludvig Bystrom
20. Olli Maata
21. Andrei Vasilevski
22. Pontus Aberg
23. Slater Koekkoek
24. Tomas Hertl
25. Thomas Wilson
26. Brady Skjei
27. Mike Matheson
28. Ville Pokka
29. Dalton Thrower
30. Stefan Matteau

The Hockey News (Adam Proteau wrote the blurb) believes the Sens need secondary scoring along with depth and sandpaper on their blueline.  They see Jakob Silfverberg and Mika Zibanejad as the next players in the pipeline, but say they “lack size.”  Silfverberg doesn’t have a big frame, but no one who has looked at Zibanejad (in person or on paper) would mistake him for a small player.  There’s no mock draft included in the issue, but purely by the rankings Hampus Lindholm would be their candidate.  Ottawa ranks fifth in THN’s “Future Watch”.  Their list of shrewd post-lockout picks are (they actually mean lockout onward, given that they include 2005 picks): Erik Karlsson, Mark Stone, Zack Smith, Erik Condra, Colin Greening, and Robin Lehner.  Their list of poor selections are Brian Lee and Jim O’Brien.

I’m not a huge fan of THN’s draft prognosis (last year they were the worst among sources as far as they ranked (three rounds)), but it’s the least expensive option available and it does provide profiles of the top-100 players.